International FootballVietnamese Football Between Collapse and Crown: What Lies Beyond the Scoreline

Vietnamese Football Between Collapse and Crown: What Lies Beyond the Scoreline

Core answer: Bóng đá Việt Nam trải qua giai đoạn trồi sụt giữa 2023 và 2025: thất bại 0-1 và 0-3 trước Indonesia tại vòng loại World Cup 2026 tháng 3 năm 2024 khiến đội bị loại, nhưng đội tuyển đã vô địch ASEAN Championship 2024 vào tháng 1 năm 2025 dưới thời huấn luyện vi

I stood in block B of My Dinh Stadium on the night of March 26, 2026, and I did not look down at the pitch. I looked at the people. After the third goal, a middle-aged man in front of me began folding his flag, very slowly, as if folding a mat after a funeral. Beside him, a boy in a number 10 shirt kept shouting for the home team to push forward. No one answered him. The pitch is never silent; only the people who sit still to listen are. On the scoreboard, the score read 0-3. Indonesia. It was the second time in five days that Vietnam had collapsed against its neighbor, following a 0-1 defeat in Jakarta on March 21, 2026. A week earlier, not many people in Hanoi believed this could happen. Vietnam had been the terror of Southeast Asian football for nearly a decade. And yet, for most of the match, they barely managed a single shot on target. I left the stands before the referee blew the final whistle. Outside the gate, a sugarcane juice vendor sat on a plastic chair, waving a paper fan, his eyes fixed on the phone replaying the match. I asked him if he was sad. He laughed: "Sad about what? I've sold here for twenty years. I've seen this team win, lose, and win again. Football is like sugarcane juice: you drink it all, and there's still pulp left." That night I did not write about the score. I wrote about the sugarcane juice vendor. Because the 0-3 scoreline is only the surface. If you read only the result, you would conclude that Vietnamese football is in free fall. But ten months later, on January 5, 2026, in Bangkok, Vietnam beat Thailand 3-2 in the second leg of the ASEAN Championship final, winning the Southeast Asian title for the third time in history. The same team, the same football nation, touching bottom and top within less than a year. A match is a broken mirror, each shard reflecting a different fate. And the story of Vietnamese football over the past two years cannot be read in a single shard. To understand those two nights, you have to go further back. The rise of Vietnamese football began on a winter afternoon in 2026, in Changzhou, China, when Vietnam's U23 team reached the final of the AFC U23 Championship for the first time in history. They lost 1-2 to Uzbekistan in a final played under falling snow, but the whole of Asia had to remember their names. The man leading them was a Korean coach named Park Hang-seo, who had taken the job a few months earlier when almost no one knew who he was. From that milestone, Vietnamese football entered a golden period that lasted nearly six years. In 2026, the senior team won the AFF Cup, beating Malaysia 3-2 on aggregate over two legs. In 2026, they reached the quarterfinals of the Asian Cup, losing only 0-1 to Japan through a penalty. That same year, Vietnam's U22 team won the SEA Games gold medal in the Philippines, and two years later defended it on home soil. In 2026, the national team reached the third round of World Cup qualifying for the first time in history, where they beat China 3-1 in Hanoi on Lunar New Year's Day. That was the period when I, as a Vietnamese working for the Chinese sports market, lived inside a strange paradox. Where I lived, people spoke of Vietnamese football as an enviable phenomenon. Back home, every national team match turned into a national holiday, when the streets of Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City overflowed with red flags with a golden star and the sound of horns. But every golden cycle has an end. In January 2026, Park Hang-seo's contract expired and he departed after lifting Vietnamese football to a level never seen before. The Vietnam Football Federation chose Philippe Troussier, a French coach who had led several African national teams and Japan, as his successor. Troussier arrived with a clear philosophy: ball control, building from the youth ranks, and a turnover of the squad. He spoke of taking Vietnam to the 2026 World Cup. He called his team a long-term project, not a short sprint. In theory, that was a correct vision for a football nation wanting to move beyond its regional borders. But football does not live on theory. It lives on results, and the results came very slowly. In 2026, Vietnam lost 0-2 to China in a friendly, lost to Uzbekistan, drew with opponents they were expected to beat. But public opinion remained patient, because the 2026 World Cup qualifiers had only just begun. What was coming would come, and it came in March 2026. The 0-1 defeat to Indonesia in Jakarta on March 21, 2026 was shocking, but people still believed it was an accident. Five days later, at My Dinh, Vietnam lost 0-3. There was no accident left to speak of. It was the first time in years that Vietnam had lost two consecutive matches to Indonesia, and it was also the end of the 2026 World Cup dream at the second qualifying round. Philippe Troussier was dismissed immediately after that defeat. The Vietnam Football Federation brought in Kim Sang-sik, another Korean coach, who had once served as an assistant to Park Hang-seo in the early period. In May 2026, he officially took charge of a team in disarray and a public trust in tatters. What happened between those two milestones, and what happened afterward to bring the team back to a regional title? The answer does not lie in the scoreline of two matches, but deeper, in the structure of the football nation and in the way people look at it. When analyzing the collapse against Indonesia, most commentary focused on one keyword: naturalization. In recent years, Indonesian football has pushed to naturalize players of Indonesian descent playing in Europe. Names like Jay Idzes, Ragnar Oratmangoen, Thom Haye, and Rafael Struick appeared in the squad, bringing experience from the top leagues of the Netherlands, Belgium, and England. On the pitch at My Dinh that night, the difference in physicality and speed of ball handling was visible to the naked eye. The Indonesian players contested more strongly, handled the ball at higher speed, and, most importantly, held their shape even when trailing. Those are the qualities of players trained in the elite professional environments of European football. But to attribute everything to naturalization is to miss most of the story. Vietnam is not without naturalized players. The national team had used foreign-born players, and by 2026, the striker Nguyen Xuan Son, a naturalized player of Brazilian origin, had become an important factor in the ASEAN Championship campaign. The question is not whether to naturalize, but how the football nation operates behind those names. Based on my experience following matches, there is a technical detail rarely mentioned in the 0-3 defeat. Indonesia did not press frantically as people assumed. They deliberately conceded possession at certain stages, kept a deep block, and waited for mistakes from Vietnam's midfield. When they won the ball, they switched states within three to four seconds, aiming straight at the gap between Vietnam's two center-backs. That was a carefully prepared tactical plan, not luck. And to counter such a plan, Vietnam needed a well-organized defense, a midfield that could control tempo, and an attack that could take its chances. In that match, all three lines had problems. But the root lies deeper than one match. It lies in the national league, where most Vietnamese players are trained and grow up. The V-League, the top tier of Vietnamese football, has existed for more than twenty years. During that time, it produced a rare generation of talent: Nguyen Quang Hai, Nguyen Cong Phuong, Doan Van Hau, Nguyen Tien Linh, Do Hung Dung. But the V-League also carries structural diseases that remain unresolved. The first is the ownership model. Many V-League clubs are owned by large corporations, often referred to affectionately as the "bau." This model has the advantage of injecting money quickly, but it also creates dependence on individual goodwill. When a business struggles, the club struggles with it, and the players are the first to pay the price. The second is the issue of finance and sustainability. Not many V-League clubs can sustain themselves through ticket revenue, television rights, and commerce. Most depend on sponsorship from their owners. That makes transfer and youth development decisions short-term, chasing immediate results. The third, and perhaps the most serious, is competitive integrity. In recent years, Vietnamese football has repeatedly seen cases involving match-fixing and illegal betting, with players and officials under investigation. Each such case not only destroys the careers of those involved but also erodes the audience's trust in the legitimacy of the league. I remember a night in Shenzhen, where I live and work, watching a V-League match on a low-quality streaming site, the image blurry and the Vietnamese commentary ringing out mixed with static. There were only a few hundred people in the stands. In one corner of the pitch, a young substitute came on in the 85th minute and touched the ball exactly twice before the referee blew the final whistle. I wondered what he thought during those two minutes. A player's youth is the only thing that cannot be extended by contract, and in Vietnam, so much youth is burned on empty stands like that. These structural diseases are nothing new. They existed in parallel with the golden period of the national team. For nearly six years under Park Hang-seo, the national team won thanks to a generation of talented players discovered and trained at a special historical moment, together with a coach who knew how to extract the maximum from limited resources. The success of the national team, to some degree, obscured the weakness of the system beneath it. As that generation aged, as Quang Hai, Cong Phuong, and Van Hau passed twenty-five, that concealment gradually disappeared. That is the real reason for the 0-3 defeat. Not because Indonesia suddenly became great, but because Vietnam had gradually exhausted the resources accumulated in the past while not yet building new ones. Interestingly, in Asian football, this story is not unique. Chinese football, the market I work in, went through a similar cycle. They once poured hundreds of millions of dollars into international stars, once brought the national team close to a World Cup, and then watched the collapse of major clubs and the stagnation of the national team. Both football nations learned the same lesson: money and stars can buy short-term success, but cannot buy a system. In Vietnam, after the collapse, the public reaction split into two streams. The first demanded more naturalization, more spending, every possible means to catch up with Indonesia and Thailand. The second argued for patience, for building from the roots, and for accepting that sustainable success cannot come in one or two seasons. Both streams have their own logic, but both overlook a more important question: whom is the Vietnamese football system operating to serve? If it serves the results of the national team, then all resources will be poured into a small group of players and a few international tournaments. If it serves the development of millions of people who play football, then it needs to be built entirely differently. When Kim Sang-sik took charge in May 2026, he inherited a wounded team. He did not have much time, because the 2026 ASEAN Championship would take place at the end of the year. He chose a pragmatic path: stabilize the defense, build a style based on solidity, and make the most of the players in the best form. Unlike Troussier, who pursued a ball-control philosophy, Kim Sang-sik accepted that Vietnam did not need to play beautifully to win. He let the team play in a way suited to the players available, accepted tight matches, and waited for the moments of brilliance from individuals. It was a compromise, but sometimes a well-timed compromise is more effective than a perfect vision set at the wrong moment. Throughout the 2026 ASEAN Championship, Vietnam did not play glamorous football. They won through discipline, through timely goals, and through a new factor that emerged: Nguyen Xuan Son. This Brazilian-born striker scored regularly, became the main marksman, and created a threat that opposing defenses could not ignore. He is proof that naturalization can bring immediate results, if used correctly. But tragedy also came to Xuan Son right at his peak. In the second leg of the final in Bangkok, he suffered a serious injury and had to leave the pitch. It was an image full of symbolism: the hero of a journey that had only just begun was forced to stop just as people started to believe in him. A transfer is not a transaction; it is a farewell wrapped in silver paper, and in the case of naturalized players, that farewell also carries the question of identity. On January 5, 2026, Vietnam lifted the ASEAN Championship trophy. The whole country took to the streets. The streets of Hanoi again overflowed with red flags. On social media, people praised Kim Sang-sik as a new hero. As for me, I remembered the sugarcane juice vendor outside the My Dinh gate, who had told me that football is like sugarcane juice: you drink it all, and there is still pulp left. The joy of winning is real, and no one has the right to take it away. But this is where I want to pose a difficult question, because I believe a football nation only matures when it dares to look directly at what lies behind the glory. That question is: what did the 2026 ASEAN Championship title conceal? Because in essence, a win in a regional tournament does not erase the fact that Vietnam was eliminated at the second round of the 2026 World Cup qualifiers, behind both Indonesia and Iraq. A Southeast Asian tournament and a World Cup qualifying campaign are two measures at two different levels, and confusing them is one of the most dangerous blind spots of regional football. There is a notable pattern in how Vietnamese football reacts to crisis. After every major defeat, the public demands a coaching change. After every major victory, the public again believes that all problems have been solved. That loop keeps the football nation from ever touching its real structural problems, because it is always swept up in the emotion of the most recent match. The second blind spot lies in the very belief in naturalization as a solution. Naturalization can bring a striker who scores twenty goals a season, but it cannot bring a youth development system that operates effectively for the next twenty years. If a football nation uses naturalization to compensate for the weakness of its system, then it is borrowing against the future to pay for the present. That debt will come due, and when it does, people will again see 0-3 defeats at My Dinh. I am not opposed to naturalization. I am opposed to turning it into a substitute for long-term thinking. Indonesia naturalizes, but Indonesia is also investing in academies and in sending young players abroad. Vietnam is doing the same, with young players sent to Japan, Korea, and Europe. The difference is not whether to naturalize, but whether the football nation has a vision or only a reaction. The third blind spot, and perhaps the hardest to accept, lies in the public itself. Vietnamese fans are one of the most passionate and loyal fan communities in Asia. But that passion sometimes becomes a pressure that keeps the football nation from daring to experiment, from daring to accept short-term failure in exchange for long-term success. Troussier tried to change things, and he was discarded after fourteen months, while a squad turnover cycle needs at least three to four years. Here, I want to tell another story. I once covered a match in Changzhou, where Vietnam lost in the final under falling snow. That day, after the final whistle, the young Vietnamese players did not cry. They stood on the pitch, bowed to the crowd, and walked in a line toward the tunnel. In the stands, thousands of Vietnamese fans kept clapping, without stopping. Applause echoing in an empty stadium sounds like a heart comforting itself. I tell that story not to romanticize defeat. I tell it to remind that Vietnamese football once had something more precious than victory: a generation of players who dared to stand on a snowy pitch and salute the crowd after losing. That spirit, not the trophies, is the real asset of the football nation. And that spirit can only be nurtured by a system that knows how to cherish it. There is one thing that I, as a Vietnamese living and working in China, see more clearly than those at home. Football in Southeast Asia and football in East Asia nurture passion in two different ways. The stands in Vietnam are fervent, spontaneous, full of emotion, where people sing, cry, and embrace each other as if the team were part of their own flesh and blood. The stands in China, by contrast, are orderly, organized, and carry a different pressure: the pressure of a nation wanting to prove something to the world. But deep down, both share the same longing: to be recognized. Vietnamese fans want the world to see them as more than a small country in Southeast Asia. Chinese fans want the world to see them as more than a large economy. And in both cases, football becomes a mirror in which they look at themselves. I go to the stadium not to watch football, but to watch what people believe in. So, after all this, where is Vietnamese football at the start of 2026? It is in a position many football nations envy: it has a generation of talented players, a coach who knows how to use the resources available, a loyal fan community, and a regional title just won. That is a good foundation. But a foundation is not a building. What Vietnamese football needs now is not a new coach, nor a new naturalized striker. What it needs is the patience to build what cannot be seen in a single match: a transparent and sustainable national league, a youth development system with a clear pathway, and a football culture that accepts that failure is part of the process, not a verdict. I am writing this at the start of 2026, as the regular season returns to its rhythm. The V-League will begin again, with matches on green pitches, with stands sometimes full and sometimes empty, with young players waiting for a chance and veterans fighting against time. Somewhere in those matches, an eighteen-year-old will score his first career goal, and a thirty-four-year-old will salute the crowd for the last time. None of them will make the front page, but all of them are part of a larger story. Vietnamese football does not lack nights of glory. It lacks ordinary Wednesday afternoons, when there is no trophy, no fervent crowd, only twenty-two people running on grass and a few hundred spectators sitting quietly watching. Those afternoons are where a football nation is truly built, and that is also the place the scoreline never fully tells. I believe Vietnamese football will return to a World Cup, sooner or later. But I also believe the most memorable moment will not be the moment the team secures qualification, but the moment people realize that qualification is no longer a miracle, but the natural result of a system built correctly over many years. Until then, every match is still a broken mirror, and each of us must find our own shard.