International FootballImage Consulting Contracts: A Veil for Unpaid Wages in V.League

Image Consulting Contracts: A Veil for Unpaid Wages in V.League

Core answer: Bài viết điều tra hiện tượng các CLB tại V.League sử dụng hợp đồng tư vấn hình ảnh giả để che giấu nợ lương cầu thủ sau đại dịch COVID-19, dựa trên phân tích các báo cáo tài chính. Key facts: - Chi phí 'tư vấn hình ảnh' tăng 240% giai đoạn 2020–2023 khi quỹ lương giảm 18% tại 8 CLB. - Một cựu tuyển thủ quốc gia bị nợ lương 3 năm liên tiếp, buộc phải giải nghệ sớm. - VFF chưa có cơ chế đối chiếu hợp đồng lao động và hợp đồng tư vấn. Source attribution: VuaBong.vn (bài viết gốc) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Làm thế nào để phát hiện nợ lương qua hợp đồng tư vấn? A: Soi báo cáo tài chính của CLB, tìm chi phí quảng cáo tăng bất thường nhưng không có sản phẩm nghiệm thu. Q: V.League có biện pháp gì bảo vệ cầu thủ? A: Chưa có, chỉ dừng ở kiểm tra giấy phép tài chính của CLB, không xác minh thực tế.

When I opened the financial statement of a club currently competing in V.League, the first thing that caught my eye was not revenue or profit, but the 'image consulting services' item amounting to 9.7 billion VND – equivalent to half of the team's total wage fund. That report was signed by a board of directors where three subsidiary companies shared the same address. Numbers cannot lie, but the people who write financial reports can. I began to trace this cash flow and eventually uncovered a perfect veil for prolonged unpaid wages. The COVID-19 pandemic has exposed what image contracts try to hide: unpaid wages are the truth, reputation is just a project. After 2026, when sponsors withdrew, many clubs in Vietnam fell into a liquidity crisis. Instead of admitting they had no money, they created fake contracts to turn the wage fund into advertising costs. Players received no salary, but the club's books recorded increased expenses, even reducing taxes. Following matches in my decade of observing Vietnamese football, I have never seen an image consulting company truly fulfill the literal meaning of the term. They do not design logos, create communication plans, or organize events. They only issue invoices for the exact amount the management wants to hide. I found a contract buried under three layers of appendices and a layer of silence. In Appendix 2, clause 4.7 stipulated that the club must pay the full contract value before the consulting company provided any service. In return, the company issued a complete invoice. No one asked whether the service was real. This mechanism is not unique to one club. I cross-referenced data from eight clubs in V.League and First Division from 2026 to 2026. The results show that 'image consulting' costs rose by an average of 240% during pandemic years, while wage funds decreased by 18%. This correlation is not accidental. It reflects systematic behavior: unpaid wages were restructured into debts with shell companies owned by the club chairman. When players demanded their rights, the club's legal department would present consulting contracts to claim they had already spent money properly. Football is not clean, but financial reports teach me how to find stains line by line. The line here is 'advertising and marketing expenses' – a familiar hiding place for funds that never reach workers' accounts. In a specific case, the captain of a central region club agreed to reduce his salary by 30% to help the club survive the pandemic. He received nothing after that agreement. The club said they had transferred money into his 'personal brand development fund.' He never received a report on that fund. When he took the club to court, the consulting contract showed that the amount had been transferred to a subsidiary of his own – a company he had no knowledge of. From a legal perspective, these agreements are hard to break because they are presented as commercial transactions between independent legal entities. But in reality, one individual can sit on both sides of the negotiating table. The Vietnam Football Federation (VFF) has regulations on professional club licensing, requiring clubs to demonstrate financial capacity. However, these regulations only stop at checking the financial reports provided by the club itself. There is no cross-checking mechanism between labor contracts, sponsorship contracts, and shell companies. A contrarian view holds that hiring external companies for image management and media is an inevitable trend in professional football worldwide. In Europe, investment funds often stand behind complex transfers. But the difference lies in transparency. Service contracts in V.League usually do not include product acceptance clauses. Employees of consulting companies – if any – cannot answer a simple question: what did they do to deserve billions of dong? Their silence is the strongest evidence. But this silence is not recorded in any judgment because players lack resources to fight. I recall meeting a former national team player who had to retire early due to three consecutive years of unpaid wages. He said that after each meeting with club leaders, he was asked to sign an acknowledgment that he had received money, but the amount was only a line in accounting books, never existing in his bank account. He feared that if he refused to sign, he would be ostracized and not allowed to play. His story replicates the pattern of workers in industrial zones owed wages, but in a more sophisticated version with sports attire, press statements, and signing ceremonies with bright smiles. To change this situation, intervention from labor unions and tax authorities is needed. Clubs must disclose the list of parent companies, subsidiaries, and related parties. Consulting contracts of significant value must be registered with the VFF to be compared with on-field reality. Players also need protection through an independent labor arbitration mechanism, rather than facing complex commercial codes. Otherwise, V.League will continue to be a place where the most valuable contracts are not signed on the pitch, but in accounting offices. And players – those who make the league's brand – will continue to be creditors who never receive an answer.
Cầu thủ liên quan